Location: The Social, London

The Social might be operated by Heavenly Recordings, but tonight’s show is a City Slang double bill, with labelmates Dear Reader and Laura Gibson getting together to launch their new albums, which were both released a week ago. The place is cosy in the extreme – the kind of place where encores have to follow on from the main set without a break, because the drummer can’t leave the stage without dismantling his kit – and as such it’s an ideal venue for the two singer songwriters to introduce the audience to their latest work.
Dear Reader, the musical project of South African-born Berlin-based Cherilyn MacNeil, is first up. MacNeil, who performs the whole set from behind her keyboard, is accompanied by a band who struggle to fit all of their instruments on the stage. They all seem to be multi-instrumentalists: violin, accordion, mandolin and trumpet are all employed, while the bass is passed around between them at various points.
The new Dear Reader album, Idealistic Animals, is a kind of musical bestiary: each track has the name of an animal, which is then used as a jumping off point for exploring more expansive themes and, ultimately, for examining MacNeil’s loss of religious faith. There are no references to this inverted Damascene conversion tonight, however. The instrumentation and occasionally baroque style means that an almost Arcade Fire level of grandiosity often seeps into the performance, but MacNeil seems content to focus on the small quirky details. Thus the songs about animals are presented as nothing more than songs about animals.
Idealistic Animals isn’t the first time that MacNeil has used something drawn from nature as a starting point: this is proved by the highlight of the set, a rousing rendition of ‘Great White Bear’, taken from her 2009 album Replace Why With Funny. Dear Reader conclude with ‘Monkey’, which climaxes with MacNeil repeating ‘You can go home now’. But the prospect of Laura Gibson means that few are inclined to do so.
Gibson’s set is very much in the spirit of the album launch. A couple of older tracks are thrown into the mix, but tonight is all about showcasing her new release, La Grande, and she plays every song from the new album. She begins with the title track, and then moves onto the more delicate ‘Milk-Heavy, Pollen Eyed’: a superb way of starting the set, but one that left me concerned that she was using up La Grande’s finest tracks rather quickly. However, her performance of the rest of the album is a reminder that La Grande is comprised almost entirely of songs of equally great strength, and so the quality of songwriting never lets up.
There are a few incidents that make Gibson’s set feel rather shambolic. Early on, she forgets to move her capo and briefly plays her guitar out of tune. Then there are lengthy backstories to several songs, and a lengthy hesitation while Dear Reader’s Cherilyn MacNeil is fetched to contribute harmonies to ‘Feather Lungs’. But Gibson and her band take the minor mishaps in their stride, and ensure that things which might easily be considered annoying are instead almost charming. But if these accidents must somehow be redeemed, then Gibson’s finer moments, such as her acapella performance of ‘The Rushing Dark’ with backing vocals provided by the audience, suffice in themselves.
VN:F [1.9.10_1130]
Rating: 0.0/10 (0 votes cast)